- The user has reviewed the auto-generated reply text and wants Claude to revise it.
- A draft needs to move to “queued” or “cancelled” without posting.
- The user wants to mark the reply as posted with a live URL — use mark_reply_posted instead.
- The user wants to schedule it for a specific date — use schedule_reply.
- The reply doesn’t exist yet — replies are created via the Reddit/HN UI’s Generate Reply button.